9/11: A quarter of a century between then and now

This year, Rosh Hashanah Eve fell on September 11. A quarter of a century between then and now.  On the morning of the holiday, I was asked by a freind: “Where were you, and how did you first learn about the events of 9/11?”

“Where were you, and what were you doing when something colossal happened?” is a fairly common question. I encounter it often in relation to October 7, and the more the question is asked, the more it dawns on me that the moment we first learn of an event is nothing compared with the days, months, and years it takes us to comprehend the magnitude of a catastrophe.

That morning, we shared where we had been, who we had been with, how we had reacted, and how the attack on the Twin Towers had affected us across the distance of time.

I was sixteen when I watched the television footage, replayed over and over again on every channel, of planes crashing into buildings. This was after the terrorist attacks that had already taken place in Israel during that period — and twenty-two years before October 7.

Locating myself along this timeline helps me make sense of things, anchors me in the here and now, and allows me to weave together loose threads of memory that have unravelled along the way.

In the days leading up to Rosh Hashanah, a trend appeared on Facebook in which people could upload photographs of themselves and see what they might have looked like had they lived in the 1980s. Or, more precisely, what we might have looked like had we followed the fashions of the time, had we been film and television stars, and, inevitably, had we been ‘American’.

The idea of using artificial intelligence to embark on a visual time and space travel did not appeal to me, if only because of the sudden realization that the 1980s were before October 7, before 9/11, before this very moment.

Something about scrolling through the beautiful images of my friends online brought me face to face with the recognition that we have reached a point of no return: At this point even the super-powers of artificial intelligence cannot blur what has already been inscribed and seared deeply into the body of knowledge that I am.

I listened to an interview with Gloria Steinem, the journalist who, alongside other women, helped advance the women’s movement in the United States and advocated for abortion rights at a time when abortion was illegal in the country. (In 2026, abortion remains illegal in thirteen U.S. states, while in Israel, a woman seeking full coverage for an abortion through the public healthcare system must receive approval from a pregnancy termination committee.)

Steinem died on September 2, 2026. Shortly afterwards, Netflix released an interview with her in which she spoke about the investigative work she undertook to expose the inequality and injustice behind Hugh Hefner’s Playboy empire. For the investigation, she went undercover as a Playboy Bunny herself.

I remember that in the year of the Twin Towers attack, girls in my year at school dressed up as Playboy Bunnies for Purim… Writing these words makes me think about the teenagers I’m going to meet in a couple of days at a Sex-Ed workshop I’ll be facilitating on healthy and positive sexuality…

The year was 2001 — five years before Tarana Burke founded the Me Too movement, and sixteen years before #MeToo went viral, irreversibly transforming public awareness around sexual harassment and sexual violence.

It’s September 2026 and I wonder whether sixteen-year-old girls will dress up as Playboy Bunnies again this coming Purim — and, if they do, what might lead them to choose that costume.

Throughout her career, Steinem recounts, she was sometimes given investigative assignments and at other times denied them because of — and on account of — her beauty. Recognizing how far we have come since the 1980s leaves me with little nostalgia for historical moments in which women did not have the right to choose how to treat their bodies and their lives. And yet that history is, in part, still our present.

On the morning of Rosh Hashanah, before setting out for a walk, and after asking and answering where we had been when the planes crashed into the WTC on September 11, 2001, we opened Jonathan Safran Foer’s Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close. Published in 2005, the novel follows nine-year-old Oskar on his journey toward acknowledging that his father did, indeed, die in the attacks, moving from the uncertainty of ambiguous loss toward the painful certainty of loss.

When the book came into my hands twenty years ago, I devoured it over three days while I was ill in bed. Reading its printed pages, interspersed with photographs and enigmatic visual elements, helped me make sense of an event that had happened far enough away for distance to preserve the illusion that “I wasn’t deeply affected.”

Reading Foer’s novel made me realize that neither geographical distance nor the passage of time had diminished the extent to which September 11 affected my own sense of safety, as well as that of many others who have been impacted by US culture.

Twelve years after 9/11, while studying for my master’s degree at Oxford University, I was asked to write a seminar paper for a course dealing with questions of authenticity and reproduction in visual culture and art through the photographic medium. I chose to write about September 11, drawing on Foer’s novel as well as its 2011 film adaptation.

After our morning conversation, I retrieved the paper I had written fourteen years ago from my hard drive and read it again. I have no doubt that had I written it after October 7, it would have been an entirely different paper. But with this catastrophe, unlike in 2001, I made a deliberate choice not to watch the videos. By then, I had already come to understand some of the ways in which media can use human grief to produce trauma on a mass scale.

All of this brings me to the approaching elections in Israel, and to the question: in light of history, and in light of our present reality, how do we choose a leadership we can trust not to create further collective trauma, only to later present itself as the force invested in healing it?

It is a vast question, and I do not have an answer. What I do know is that, within a constantly-changing reality, creating islands of sanity, joy, serendipity, pleasure, listening, inspiration, and curiosity is part of my life’s work. I remain committed to this work in my own private life, in the hope that individual action may also seep into collective consciousness.

I will end with a quote from the interview with Gloria Steinem (1934–2026): “Hope is a form of planning.”

For those who would like to read further, my 2012 essay on the use of photography in the media in the aftermath of September 11 is available here: Extremely-Loud-Incredebly-Close_essay-Liza_Futerman_2012

Sign-in to Get Liza's latest articles

liza futerman

Liza Futerman

My lifelong goal is to spread awareness about the intricacies of our nervous systems, emphasizing the importance of tuning into our bodies as a pathway to enhancing resilience both on an individual level and within our communities.

More on the same topic: